Questions about the Canon EF-S 10-22mm f/3.5-4.5 USM

Alex writes to ask about the Canon EF-S 10-22mm f/3.5-4.5 USM:

I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and have noticed that you haven’t commented on the Canon 10-22mm lens on a crop camera. I have a 350D with the 10-22mm lens. I’m curious as to your opinion on using this lens on a crop body compared to the 17-40mm. I’m considering upgrading to the 5D at some point and would obvioulsy need to purchase a WA lens as well. You seem to be satisfied with your result of using the 17-40 on a crop body in the past or did it make a noticeable difference to you when you moved from the crop body to the full frame on the 5D with your 17-40mm?

Thanks for writing, Alex. You are right that I haven’t written about this lens, but only because I don’t have any direct experience with it. Being an EF-S lens, it is designed for use only on crop sensor Canon bodies (like the 350D/400D series and the 20D/30D/40D series), and I’m using full frame these days.

You are also correct that I’m a big fan of the Canon EF 17-40mm f/4 L lens. I used this lens on the crop sensor camera that I had until about a year ago, and I continue to make a lot of use of this lens on my 5D. On my crop sensor body, the 17-40 always produced excellent center sharpness, though it could be a bit soft in the corners, especially when shot wide open. I find it to be even better on full frame where I frequently shoot it at f/11 or even f/16, thus controlling the corner softness/fall-off issues more effectively.

On a crop sensor body, the 10-22mm focal length range is essentially equivalent to the 16-35mm range on a full frame body – in other words just a tiny bit wider than my 17-40mm lens on full frame. Although I had thought that 17-40mm was “wide enough” on my crop sensor body, once I started shooting full frame with this lens I really came to appreciate the much wider coverage provided by this combination. I think that the combination of the 350D and the 10-22mm lens could very useful – for example, it could be a wonderful small and lightweight setup for doing landscape photography while hiking or backpacking.

With that in mind, I guess you could say that I was satisfied with the 17-40 on the crop sensor camera at that time, but that I know realize that if I were going to again use a crop sensor body I would almost certainly want to get a lens providing the coverage of the 10-22. Although I haven’t used the EFS 10-22mm lens myself, almost everything I’ve read about it has been positive.

When you do move to that full frame body you might find that the 17-40 really comes into its own, especially if you shoot landscapes and similar subjects. As to whether you would want to get this lens now or wait, I think that depends upon what kind of coverage your other lenses currently provide in that range.

Join the discussion —  leave a comment or question. (Comments are moderated and may not appear immediately. Links in comments may be removed.)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.